Every genuine cafe, coffee shop and tea room on Hayling Island, from the old Hayling Billy Trail to the seafront.
We pulled the live Google rating and review count for every genuine cafe across Hayling Island (checked 2026-09-28), and ranked them the same way as every other guide on haylingisland.co: highest star rating first, ties broken by review count, anything under 50 reviews listed after the rest. Nobody paid to be on this list.
1Bronte’s Cafe
★ 4.9 · 88 Google reviews. Havant Rd., Hayling Island PO11 0LP
Good to know: Hours: Sunday8 am–3 pm; MondayClosed; TuesdayClosed; Wednesday8 am–3 pm; Thursday8 am–3 pm; Friday8 am–3 pm; Saturday8 am–4 pm. Phone 07743 901930. Food hygiene rating: not found on the FSA register.
2Hayling Billy Bites
★ 4.9 · 79 Google reviews · Food hygiene 5 (October 2025). Hayling Billy Trail, Hayling Island PO11 0LG
Good to know: Hours: Sunday8 am–3 pm; MondayClosed; TuesdayClosed; WednesdayClosed; Thursday8 am–3 pm; Friday8 am–5 pm; Saturday8 am–3 pm. Phone 07783 084780. Website https://www.facebook.com/LeTubeCafe/?_rdr. Food hygiene 5 (October 2025).
3Up The Creek Café
★ 4.8 · 168 Google reviews · Food hygiene 5 (May 2025). 28 Creek Rd, Hayling Island PO11 9RD
Good to know: Hours: Sunday9 am–1 pm; Monday7:30 am–2 pm; Tuesday7:30 am–2 pm; Wednesday7:30 am–2 pm; Thursday7:30 am–2 pm; Friday7:30 am–2 pm; Saturday9 am–2 pm. Phone 07834 688023. Website http://www.facebook.com/upthecreek1. Food hygiene 5 (May 2025).
4MadHatters Tea Room & Gift Shop
★ 4.7 · 411 Google reviews · Food hygiene 5 (July 2024). 232B Sea Front, Hayling Island PO11 0AU
Good to know: Hours: Sunday9 am–4 pm; MondayClosed; TuesdayClosed; Wednesday9 am–4 pm; Thursday9 am–4 pm; Friday9 am–4 pm; Saturday9 am–4 pm. Phone 07784 944455. Website http://www.madhattershayling.com/. Food hygiene 5 (July 2024).
5Three beans & a tea leaf
★ 4.7 · 188 Google reviews · Food hygiene 5 (June 2025). 33 Station Rd, Hayling Island PO11 0EA
Good to know: Hours: SundayClosed; Monday10 am–3 pm; Tuesday10 am–3 pm; WednesdayClosed; Thursday10 am–3 pm; Friday10 am–3 pm; Saturday10 am–3 pm. Phone 023 9246 7791. Website https://www.facebook.com/threebeansandatealeaf/. Food hygiene 5 (June 2025).
6Ollie’s Coffee
★ 4.7 · 157 Google reviews · Food hygiene 5 (May 2024). 7 Southwood Rd, Hayling Island PO11 9PS
Reviewers most often mention bagels (14 mentions), cake (12 mentions) and smoothies (9 mentions).
Good to know: Hours: Sunday8 am–4 pm; Monday8 am–4 pm; Tuesday8 am–4 pm; Wednesday8 am–4 pm; Thursday8 am–4 pm; Friday8 am–4 pm; Saturday8 am–4 pm. Website https://instagram.com/ollieshaylingisland. Food hygiene 5 (May 2024).
7Mike’s Kitchen
★ 4.7 · 128 Google reviews · Food hygiene 5 (May 2025). 7 Mengham Rd, Hayling Island PO11 9BG
Reviewers most often mention friendly staff (30 mentions), quality produce (6 mentions) and outdoor seating (5 mentions).
Good to know: Hours: SundayClosed; MondayClosed; Tuesday9:30 am–2 pm; Wednesday9:30 am–2 pm; Thursday9:30 am–2 pm; Friday9:30 am–2 pm; Saturday9:30 am–2 pm. Phone 023 9246 0560. Website https://keuga.top/chives-zj-mj58. Food hygiene 5 (May 2025).
8Northney Farm Tea Rooms
★ 4.6 · 1133 Google reviews · Food hygiene 5 (July 2026). Hayling Island PO11 0RX
Good to know: Hours: Sunday10 am–5 pm; Monday10 am–5 pm; Tuesday10 am–5 pm; Wednesday10 am–5 pm; Thursday10 am–5 pm; Friday10 am–5 pm; Saturday10 am–5 pm. Phone 023 9246 7607. Website https://www.northneyfarmtearooms.com/. Food hygiene 5 (July 2026).
The verdict
On the numbers, Bronte’s Cafe is the top-rated cafe in Hayling Island — 4.9 stars from 88 Google reviews.
How we ranked them
1. Which businesses: every genuine cafe on Google Maps across Hayling Island with a real rating. Wrong-category results the same search turned up are excluded by hand.
2. Order: Google star rating, highest first, ties broken by review count. Under 50 reviews is listed after the rest.
3. “Mentioned in X reviews” figures come straight from the review topics Google shows on each listing — real customer language, not picked or edited by us.
4. Nobody paid to be on this list, and nobody can pay to move up it.
Spotted something out of date? Tell us and we'll check it.